For Saint Thomas Aquinas, the notion of law is situated within a broader metaphysical and theological context, which modern theories of law have largely abandoned. In order to recover the wisdom of Saint Thomas on the topic of law, the 2024 Rome seminar will consider this question: what is the relationship between grace, virtue, and law?

More specifically, what is law, considered in relation to these other principles? Saint Thomas Aquinas teaches that law and grace are exterior principles (derived from principium meaning beginning or source) of human action, whereas virtue is an interior principle of human action. As an exterior principle of human acts, law acts as their rule and measure. The proper effect of all law is to make a person good by ordering them to natural and supernatural virtue. Our consideration of these three distinct, although related, proximate principles of good human action will be situated within the overarching Thomistic truth that the ultimate principle inclining a person to good action is God, “who both instructs him by His law and assists him by His grace” (Summa Theologiae I-II, q. 90, prooemium).

Saint Thomas gives a comprehensive definition of law according to its four causes: law is an ordinance of reason (formal cause) for the common good (final cause) made by him who has care of the community (efficient cause) and promulgated (material cause). Law binds a person to act in accordance with reason — both human and divine reason.

All three principles lead man to act in accordance with human and divine reason, but each in a different respect. Through the promulgation of the four kinds of law — divine, eternal, natural, and human — all of which participate variously in Eternal Truth, God both teaches man what his end is (happiness) and also interiorly him to attain that end through virtuous activity. A careful study of all three principles, each one acting as a secondary proximate cause of God’s primary causality as He moves all creatures back to Himself, is necessary for a true account of the nuanced complexity of a person’s journey homeward to communion with the Holy Trinity through graced human acts. With Saint Thomas as our guide, our seminar discussions will include the following topics:

• Anthropological Foundations: Natural Inclinations as the Ground of Precepts of the Natural Law
• Natural Law and its Connaturality
• Natural Virtues, Supernatural Virtues, and Infused Moral Virtues
• Relationship between Old and New Law
• Pneumatological Dimensions of a Thomistic Theology of Grace